Pine Island, NY Real Estate

Pine Island NY Real Estate Overview




Open Houses


Short Sales







Pine Island NY Real Estate Stats

Average Price in Pine Island: $421,100  County Average: $326,616

Average Taxes in Pine Island: $10,415  County Average: $8,801

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in Pine Island: $164  County Average: $150

Average Walkscore in Pine Island: 20  County Average: 30

Average Year Built in Pine Island: 1960  County Average: 1960

Average Days on Website in Pine Island: 82  County Average: 117

Pine Island NY Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhoods in Pine Island NY

Pine Island

Areas in Pine Island NY

Warwick Town

Most Popular Listing

Popular Pine Island Real Estate

Most Expensive Listing

Expensive Pine Island Real Estate

Least Expensive Listing

Cheap Pine Island Real Estate


Listings in Pine Island

Fantastic 4.7 acres in the heart of Pine Island's famous black dirt region...

Expanded ranch on level private lot. this home includes 3 entries, and easy access to full basement...

Beautiful home w/hardwood floors, stone fireplace and much more on over 9 acres of land in sought after neighborhood...

Opportunity knocks!!! great opportunity to build your dream home on this privately set 18+ acre lot with gorgeous views of the pochuck valley, stonewalls and horse trails or proceed with the final of a four lots subdivision...

***price reduced***don't pass this one by! 4 bedroom, 2...

Though abutting a main road this 4+ acre property offers privacy abounts...

This quiet country estate in warwick, ny, lays hillside in the picturesque landscape of the “black dirt,” a timeless retreat from the bustling world...

walk or bike ride to Pine Island's shops, restaurants, park, post office, and Pine Island brewery....

facility has many uses and is located in the hamlet of Pine Island within the town of warwick (manufacturing, distribution, warehousing/storage, etc.). zoned light industrial. current us...

Of warwick and more specifically in the hamlet of Pine Island. we’re bringing this property back to life and few creative entrepreneurs...

Build your dream home on this 2.4 acre piece of land in the heart of the "black dirt" region with beautiful views...

Here is a newly renovated raised ranch nestled upon 2...

Handy man special in warwick school district! Pine Island ranch on 1...

Possible subdivision, or build your dream home and have plenty of room for, hunting, hiking, and recreation...

This historic building in Pine Island is located on county rt 1 with excellent visibility and convenient access for clients...


a chefs kitchen that features butcher block counter tops, copper apron sink, antique Pine Island with carrera marble top. spacious living room with stone fireplace. formal dining room with doors leading out to a stone patio. beautiful wood fl...

Adorable 2 bedrooms (possible 3) cottage with detached 2 car garage and pool on ...

ft multi-use commercial building. built for the Pine Island ambulance corp. featur...

this 3 plus acre parcel is on foley road just off Pine Island turnpike and directly across from silo road....

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

Wright Bros. Real Estate
53 South Broadway
Nyack, NY